Review Policy

Review Policy

Information about the review policy.

All scientific manuscripts that meet the journal’s scope and basic requirements undergo mandatory scientific peer review.

The journal uses a double-blind peer review system.

The manuscript is sent to at least two independent reviewers who are competent in the relevant field of study.

In double-blind peer review, the author’s identity is not disclosed to the reviewer, and the reviewer’s identity is not disclosed to the author.

When assessing the manuscript, the following are considered: relevance of the study, scientific novelty, methodological validity, reliability of results, scientific and practical significance, quality of analysis and conclusions, compliance with journal scope, and adherence to publication ethics principles.

Based on the review results, one of the following decisions may be made:

  1. accept the article for publication;
  2. accept after making the necessary corrections;
  3. send the manuscript back to the author for substantial revision and re-consideration;
  4. reject the manuscript.

Peer review is conducted confidentially. Reviewers’ comments are transmitted to the author without disclosing personal data of the reviewer.

After major changes are made, the manuscript may be sent for a repeat review.

The final decision to publish is made by the editorial office, taking into account the results of peer review.

21 days
Average review time
2
Independent reviewers
38%
Acceptance rate
Double-blind
Review type
Methodology

What review method is used

The journal uses one of the following two review methods to ensure impartiality.

Standard method

Double-blind review

The author and reviewer do not know each other’s identities. The manuscript is sent to the reviewer without author information, ensuring an impartial evaluation. All original articles of the journal are reviewed using this method.

Open review

At the editor’s discretion and with the author’s consent, reviewer and author information may be disclosed in special cases, such as invited review articles.

Process

Review stages

The process a manuscript goes through from submission to publication.

1

Initial technical check

The manuscript is checked for compliance with formatting requirements and screened for plagiarism.

1–3 working days
2

An editor is assigned

An editor specializing in the relevant field conducts an initial assessment of the manuscript.

2 working days
3

Sent to reviewers

The manuscript is submitted to at least two independent specialists under a double-blind review process.

2–4 working days
4

Peer review process

Reviewers evaluate the scientific quality, methodology, and originality and provide their recommendations.

10–15 working days
5

Editorial decision

The editor makes the final decision based on the reviewers’ recommendations.

2–3 working days
6

Author notification and publication

The decision and comments are sent to the author; accepted articles are scheduled for the next issue.

1–2 working days
Result

Possible decision types

At the end of the review process, the editor makes one of three possible decisions.

Accepted

The manuscript is prepared for publication without changes or with minor technical editing.

Revision required

The author is asked to make minor or major revisions, after which the manuscript is reviewed again.

Rejected

The manuscript is rejected due to insufficient scientific quality or because it does not fit the journal’s scope.

Criteria

What reviewers look for

Each manuscript is evaluated according to the following key criteria.

1

Originality

Scientific novelty and distinction from existing research

2

Methodology

Validity of the study design and statistical analysis

3

Practical significance

Potential applicability in clinical practice

4

Use of references

Relevance and adequacy of the sources

5

Presentation quality

Clarity of language, structure, tables, and figures

6

Ethical compliance

Absence of plagiarism and availability of patient consent documents

Confidentiality

The manuscript under review and the review results are available only to the editorial office and assigned reviewers. They will not be disclosed to third parties without the author’s consent.

Appeal against the decision

An author who disagrees with the decision may submit a reasoned appeal to the editorial office. The appeal will be reviewed by an independent editor.