These guidelines are designed to help reviewers evaluate scientific manuscripts objectively, consistently, and effectively.
Reviewers assess the scientific quality, relevance, and compliance of a manuscript with the journal requirements.
The review helps authors improve their work and supports the editorial office in making an informed decision.
We recommend reviewing each manuscript in the following sequence.
Confirm that the topic matches your expertise and that there is no conflict of interest.
Assess the structure, relevance, and overall scientific quality of the manuscript.
Check the research methods and reliability of the results.
Provide clear, constructive, and useful recommendations for the author.
Select the final recommendation that reflects your review.
Each manuscript should be assessed objectively and based on evidence using the following key criteria.
| Criterion | What to assess | Score |
|---|---|---|
| Scientific novelty | Does the research offer a new scientific result, approach, or significant conclusion? | 1–5 |
| Relevance of the topic | Is the topic relevant to current scientific problems and the journal’s scope? | 1–5 |
| Methodology | Are the research methods clear, justified, and sufficient to obtain the results? | 1–5 |
| Results | Are the results clearly presented and do they support the conclusions provided? | 1–5 |
| References | Are the references sufficient, reliable, and relevant to the topic? | 1–5 |
| Language and structure | Is the manuscript logically structured, clear, and compliant with academic writing standards? | 1–5 |
Reviewers must protect the confidentiality of the manuscript and review process and follow professional ethical standards.
Do not discuss the content of the manuscript under review, author information, or review results with third parties.
If you have personal, professional, or financial interests, inform the editorial office before accepting the review.
Criticism should focus on the content and scientific aspects of the manuscript, not on the person. Provide the author with specific suggestions.
If you identify suspected plagiarism or improper use of other authors’ work, inform the editorial office.
At the end of the review, recommend one of the following outcomes to the editorial office based on the manuscript’s overall scientific quality.
The manuscript meets the main scientific and technical requirements. No major revisions are required.
The manuscript contains correctable shortcomings. The author may resubmit the manuscript after making the required revisions.
The manuscript has major scientific, methodological, or substantive problems that are difficult to resolve in its current form.
Review all criteria, state your main points clearly and constructively, and ensure that your final recommendation matches your comments.